Modeling Broad Street Station as it was in 1943
Share
About this post: it was written with AI. Claude, a model made by Anthropic, drafted it from isoscape’s code and notes and the sources listed at the end, and I reviewed it before it was published. The maps themselves I draw with isoscape, a tool I built with Claude; my artist statement says more about how I work with AI. — Chris
The first train left John Russell Pope's new station on West Broad Street on January 6, 1919. The Richmond Terminal Railway built it, and the Richmond, Fredericksburg & Potomac and the Atlantic Coast Line each owned half of that company. It went up on the site of the old State Agricultural fair grounds. The DHR calls its dome the first on a major railroad station. Behind it, the tracks ran in a loop, so a train could come in off the RF&P at one end and head out the other without turning around. During the Second World War it averaged 57 trains a day, and on April 22, 1943, a record 33,324 passengers came through.

This is the first set in a new collection I'm calling Buildings in Their Time, where one building is drawn up close in a particular year along with the places around it. Most of my maps come straight from data. For this one I also had to model the station itself from historical records, working with Claude in code.
Building the station
In OpenStreetMap the building is the Science Museum of Virginia, and there's very little about its heights. That wasn't enough to draw the front, so I modeled it in pieces: the two wings, the center pavilion, the porch with its six columns and two piers, the entablature, the drum and the dome, each set at a height above whatever it sits on. The shapes come from the 1919 plan and period postcards. The heights are scaled from photographs, so they're approximate. The concourse sits on the higher ground so it spans the tracks the way it did. The dome was still tile in 1943 (lightning damaged it in 1951 and the copper replacement was finished in 1955), so I used the tile color.

The 1925 Sanborn sheets
The 1925 Sanborn atlas mapped the station six years after it opened, and it's the best record I found of how it sat on the ground: the head house, the concourse running back over the tracks, and the long platform sheds, colored by what they were built from. The sheet labels it "Union Station" and names the owner as the Richmond Terminal Railway Co.

The next sheet, 476, follows the loop north and east past the Stephen Putney shoe works and the C.F. Sauer Company at Broad and Hermitage. The Sauer's vanilla sign is still lit on Broad Street. Buildings near the station that have since been torn down are traced from nearby sheets in the same atlas and put back on the 1943 map.

The loop
The last train left Broad Street on November 15, 1975, and the loop was pulled up after that. Today's map data has nothing for it, so I traced it from the USGS Richmond quadrangles of 1934 and 1956 and lined it up with the platforms that are still there behind the museum. Nine tracks run through the station and merge into four and then two at each end.


The other railroads on the map are today's tracks, each given a date so it only shows up in the right years, like the C&O viaduct along the river from 1901 and the Belt Line bridge from 1919. On the big map the track is drawn four times its real width so you can follow it across the city. On the single-place prints it's drawn at its real width.
What's approximate
- The station's heights, which are scaled from photographs.
- The surrounding buildings. They're the ones still standing that the city assessor dates to 1943 or earlier, plus the ones traced from the Sanborn sheets. Anything torn down that Sanborn didn't map is missing.
- The trains. They're typical of the time (a steam engine, its tender and heavyweight cars), not specific trains.
The fourteen places and their sources · Explore the 1943 map · The set in the shop
Sources
- Richmond, Fredericksburg and Potomac Railroad records: the Richmond Terminal Railway (Library of Virginia)
- Broad Street Station, National Register listing (Virginia DHR)
- Broad Street Station (SAH Archipedia)
- History of the museum: the first train, January 6, 1919 (Science Museum of Virginia)
- Railroad history: built on the State Agriculture (fair) grounds (Richmond Railroad Museum)
- Broad Street Station historical marker (HMDB)
- The busiest day at Broad Street Station, April 22, 1943 (Science Museum of Virginia)
- Sanborn Fire Insurance Map, Richmond, 1925, vol. 4 (Library of Congress)
- USGS Richmond quadrangle, 1:24,000, 1934 (PDF)
- Every place on the map, with its own sources (isoscape explorer)
- How it's made: One building, close up